Why Is There Lead in Stanley Cups and Other Reusable Water Bottles? (Updated) Leave a comment

You may see the pellet that Stanley refers to on the backside of your drink container. It seals these layers collectively the place all of them meet on the backside of the bottle, in a course of known as lead soldering. Technically, the vessel does include lead, nevertheless it’s enclosed with stainless-steel and will by no means are available in contact along with your drink or pores and skin. Nevertheless, do you have to drop the water bottle or if it in any other case will get broken and this piece of metal comes unfastened, there’s an opportunity the lead may be uncovered to your pores and skin.

Lead is a naturally occurring poisonous steel. The World Well being Group (WHO) cites that there is no safe level of lead exposure. “As soon as lead enters the physique, it’s distributed to organs such because the mind, kidneys, liver, and bones.” Excessive ranges of lead publicity may be deadly. With decrease ranges of publicity—which might occur with a microscopic quantity—lead poisoning in adults could cause nerve problems, decreased kidney operate, and fertility points. In kids, it may well trigger developmental delays and seizures. The WHO says kids are “notably susceptible to steer poisoning as a result of they take up 4 to 5 occasions as a lot ingested lead as adults.”

“Lead is ubiquitous within the atmosphere, so low ranges of each day publicity are a reality of life,” says Jane Houlihan, nationwide director of science and well being at Healthy Babies Bright Futures. “Exposures and dangers add up daily from lead in meals, water, home mud, and soil. This makes it all of the extra necessary for corporations to maintain lead out of shopper merchandise. Youngsters don’t want one other potential supply of lead of their lives.”

What Do Different Manufacturers Use?

Lead soldering is low-cost and straightforward to make use of and is a typical apply from a wide range of producers. Nevertheless, various strategies can be found. A number of of the reusable water bottle corporations we reached out to don’t use lead of their manufacturing course of. Here is the record:

• Owala (no lead), which makes widespread bottles just like the FreeSip and a Stanley-dupe tumbler, says it has by no means used lead in its manufacturing course of. “The manufacturing of vacuum-sealed containers utilizing lead-free solder is extra expensive and sophisticated. Nevertheless, we made a dedication from day one with Owala to make use of lead-free solder on our bottles,” an Owala spokesperson says.
• Hydro Flask (no lead since 2013), one other internet-famous water bottle firm, stopped using lead solder greater than 10 years in the past. “By mid-2013, the lead was out of the Hydro Flask manufacturing course of as a result of the model designed a proprietary sealant, TempShield,” a Hydro Flask spokesperson says.
• Klean Kanteen (no lead) additionally forgoes lead, as a substitute utilizing a noncrystalline silica bead to create its vacuum-insulated bottles. “The method, utilizing silica as a substitute of lead, is similar besides greater warmth is required to soften the silica,” says Wealthy Haver, the corporate’s director of world operations. Whereas some types of silica may be harmful if very wonderful particles are inhaled—sand is made out of crystalline silica, so even finer than that—this does not apply to noncrystalline silica glass. “Silica in its noncrystalline kind doesn’t have the identical respiratory well being properties as crystalline silica,” says Marty Cohen, a instructing professor within the Division of Environmental and Occupational Well being Sciences on the College of Washington.
• MiiR (lead used) confirmed its use of lead in its manufacturing course of with a few of its merchandise. In line with its website, “This pellet does include lead for manufacturing effectivity, waste discount, and to make sure an entire seal. For these causes and since there’s zero lead publicity, MiiR makes use of this course of with confidence.”
• LifeStraw (lead used) makes straws and filtered bottles that take away micro organism, microplastics, and parasites from water. We actually preferred the Go Collection Filtered Water Bottle because of this. That makes it essentially the most stunning firm to substantiate it makes use of “a lead soldering dot as a part of the manufacturing sealing course of.”
• Different manufacturers (unknown): The next corporations haven’t responded to our requests for remark: Yeti, S’well, HydroJug, and Greens Steel. (Sigg responded however has not given us a solution but. We are going to replace this story once they do.)

The Drawback With Lead in Manufacturing

Even when the cup or bottle is rarely broken and also you’re by no means uncovered to steer, if it is used within the manufacturing course of, staff are nonetheless across the materials not directly. The solder coaching institute EPTAC says on its website that the quantity of lead on solders is probably going not going to trigger extreme well being issues, however there’s nonetheless a danger for staff uncovered to steer throughout the course of.

“When lead is utilized in manufacturing, there’s a danger of lead publicity for customers of these merchandise, particularly for merchandise supposed to be used in meals consumption, like drinkware,” says a consultant for the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention. “There may be additionally a possible occupational security danger for staff and, with out correct safeguards, may very well be a danger for staff’ households by way of take-home lead exposures.”

In case your Stanley bottle or cup will get broken, you possibly can ask for a alternative underneath Stanley’s lifetime warranty. We requested Stanley if prospects may return undamaged cups, or if the corporate plans to vary its manufacturing course of, nevertheless it solely pointed us to the identical information page about its use of lead.

For those who purchase one thing utilizing hyperlinks in our tales, we might earn a fee. This helps help our journalism. Learn more.